Top-Rated Roofing Companies in Huntington, NY in 2026

Your roof is the most expensive exterior system on your home, and the wrong contractor can cost you far more than the job itself. Top-Rated Roofing Companies in Huntington are genuinely hard to separate from the storm chasers who flood Long Island after every major weather event.

Quotes look similar on paper but use completely different material grades, and insurance claims add another layer of difficulty that most homeowners aren’t ready for. After reviewing dozens of local contractors against real customer feedback and verified credentials, this guide covers the five strongest options worth your attention.

The Research Approach for This Ranking

Each contractor was assessed using publicly available sources: Google and Yelp reviews, contractor directories, Better Business Bureau profiles, and official company websites.

The goal was straightforward. Only contractors with a proven, documented track record in residential roofing on Long Island made the final list.

See the full research breakdown:

• Smart Choice Contractors – Best for residential roof replacement and repair on Long Island
• John Goess Roofing – Best for residential roofing and repair services
• Supreme Roofing & Chimney Inc. – Best for residential and commercial roofing services on Long Island and New Jersey
• Premier Roofers – Best for residential and commercial roofing services in the Tri-State region
• A-1 Roofing – Best for residential and commercial roofing services in the tri-state region

Why Top-Rated Roofing Companies In Huntington Matter

Picking the wrong roofing contractor in Huntington doesn’t just mean a bad experience. It can mean failed inspections, voided warranties, and out-of-pocket costs that insurance won’t touch.

Unlicensed storm chasers are a real problem on Long Island. They show up after every major weather event, offer low bids, and disappear before the warranty means anything.

The contractor you choose also affects how smoothly your insurance claim moves. An experienced local roofer knows how to document storm damage properly and communicate with adjusters, which changes the outcome more than most homeowners expect.

Beyond the claims process, a top-rated contractor brings better cost-per-square-foot value through quality materials, faster project completion from contract to finish, and warranty coverage that actually holds up. That combination is what separates a solid roofing investment from an expensive mistake.

Top 5 Top-Rated Roofing Companies In Huntington: Breakdown and Comparison

Note: All data in this table is sourced from review platforms and the official websites of the listed companies.

1.  Smart Choice Contractors – Best for Residential Roof Replacement and Repair on Long Island

What Does Smart Choice Contractors Do?

Based in Huntington, New York, this contractor has been providing residential roofing services throughout Nassau and Suffolk Counties since 1999. Their services include roof repair, replacement, and inspection; asphalt shingle installation; vinyl siding; and gutter guard installation.

What makes them genuinely different is their Owens Corning Platinum Preferred certification (held by only nine contractors on all of Long Island), which is how the team behind Smart Choice Contracting backs their work with 50-year full labor and material warranties. Over 2,000 completed installations and a perfect 5.0 rating across 96 reviews say a lot.

Why Does Smart Choice Contractors Stand Out as a Top-Rated Roofing Company in Huntington?

Most contractors send a salesperson to your door. Smart Choice Contractors has the owner perform every estimate personally, which keeps pricing transparent and cuts out the upsell pressure that frustrates homeowners.

Their use of hot-dip galvanized nails (outlasting standard fasteners by roughly 15 years) and that rare Platinum Preferred certification means the quality commitment shows up in the actual materials, not just the marketing.

Summary of Real User Reviews:

Customers consistently praise the thorough property cleanup after jobs, which is one of those details that separates professional crews from the ones who just want to get to the next site.

The 5.0 rating across 96 reviews is rare territory, and the 1,600+ satisfied property owners on record back it up. Transparent pricing and zero hidden fees show up as the pattern mentioned most often across the reviews.

2.  John Goess Roofing – Best for Residential Roofing and Repair Services

What Does John Goess Roofing Do?

John Goess Roofing has been serving the Westbury, NY area and surrounding communities since 1979, putting them at over 45 years in the business (not a cheap experience to replicate). They specialize in roofing and roof repair estimates, skylight repair, roof cleaning, gutter installation, and metal roofing.

Their dual certifications as a GAF Master Elite Contractor and Owens Corning Authorized Preferred Pride Contractor give them access to premium materials and extended warranty options, including a lifetime GAF System Plus Limited Warranty and a five-year workmanship guarantee.

Why Does John Goess Roofing Stand Out as a Top-Rated Roofing Company in Huntington?

Four and a half decades in the roofing business on Long Island mean this crew has seen every weather scenario the region throws at homes. That depth of local knowledge directly affects how well they diagnose and fix problems.

A clean BBB record since 2004, the Angie’s List Super Service Award, and customers repeatedly naming foreman Marcos in independent reviews all point to a team that shows up the same way every time.

Summary of Real User Reviews:

Professional skill and reasonable pricing come up as the consistent theme. The fact that a specific crew member, foreman Marcos, gets named across multiple independent reviews suggests the quality isn’t just at the top level.

It runs through the whole operation. That kind of field-level consistency is hard to manufacture and harder to fake.

3.  Supreme Roofing & Chimney Inc. – Best for Residential and Commercial Roofing Services on Long Island and New Jersey

What Does Supreme Roofing & Chimney Inc. Do?

Supreme Roofing & Chimney Inc. is a family-owned operation based in Shirley, NY, with 30 years of experience across Long Island and New Jersey. They handle roofing installation and repairs, chimney services, gutter installation and cleaning, siding, skylight installation, and custom deck building for both residential and commercial properties.

Their license number (HI-62186) is publicly listed, which matters more than most homeowners realize when comparing quotes after a storm. Free roof inspections and transparent pricing round out what is a fairly broad service range for a family-run shop.

Why Does Supreme Roofing & Chimney Inc. Stand Out as a Top-Rated Roofing Company in Huntington?

Their 24-hour emergency service directly addresses one of the most stressful roofing scenarios: a leaking roof after hours following a Long Island storm, when most contractors aren’t picking up the phone.

Three decades of working with Long Island’s coastal weather conditions also mean they understand the wind-resistance and moisture-management requirements that newer entrants to the market often underestimate.

Summary of Real User Reviews:

Client testimonials consistently point to punctuality and responsive communication as the standout qualities, which are exactly the things homeowners care about when a job is actively happening.

Reviews across multiple exterior projects, from roof repairs to chimney work, show the same level of execution regardless of the service type. Fair pricing and on-time arrival are the two things customers reference most often.

4. Premier Roofers – Best for Residential and Commercial Roofing Services in the Tri-State Region

What Does Premier Roofers Do?

Premier Roofers provides roof repairs, replacement, gutters, siding, trim, and commercial roofing across the Greater Ashland and Tri-State regions. Their GAF installer certification covers quality on the materials side, but what’s genuinely interesting is that they don’t lock customers into one brand.

Homeowners can choose alternative roofing materials rather than whatever the contractor prefers to sell. They back up their work with licensing, insurance, and warranty coverage, and offer complimentary estimates along with flexible financing options.

Why Does Premier Roofers Stand Out as a Top-Rated Roofing Company in Huntington?

Their customer-first philosophy puts the customer’s preferences ahead of the contractor’s material preferences. That’s an approach you don’t see often enough in residential roofing.

Giving homeowners actual brand choice rather than presenting one option as the only path builds a different kind of trust, and that customer-first framing runs through their entire service process.

Summary of Real User Reviews:

Published review data for Premier Roofers wasn’t available at the time of research, so the assessment here leans on their stated service philosophy and certification credentials.

What is clear is that the customer-choice model and the transparency around assessments and costs reflect a business approach designed to build long-term trust. That kind of positioning tends to attract repeat clients and referrals over time.

5. A-1 Roofing – Best for Residential and Commercial Roofing Services in the Tri-State Region

What Does A-1 Roofing Do?

A-1 Roofing operates out of Chesapeake, OH, covering residential and commercial customers across Ohio, West Virginia, and Kentucky. They install and repair asphalt shingles, metal roofing, and rubber roofing, and also handle chimney repair, siding, gutters, soffit, fascia, drywall, flooring, and painting (think full exterior restoration, not just the roof).

Free estimates, a 60-second financing pre-qualification process, and warranty coverage on completed work make accessibility a clear priority for both homeowners and commercial property owners.

Why Does A-1 Roofing Stand Out as a Top-Rated Roofing Company in Huntington?

The breadth of services beyond roofing means a homeowner dealing with storm damage doesn’t have to coordinate four different contractors to fix everything that got hit. Their flexible financing model, including rapid pre-qualification, removes the barrier that stops many homeowners from completing necessary roof repairs before damage compounds.

Summary of Real User Reviews:

Multiple five-star reviews call out hard-working crews, professional communication, and an owner who takes accountability seriously. Customers aren’t just satisfied with the finished product.

They’re noting the quality of the experience during the job, which points to a team that treats each project as more than a one-time transaction. That kind of repeat praise across both repair and installation work is a strong reliability signal.

Research Methodology and Selection Process

The goal of this research was to surface roofing companies in and around Huntington, NY, that homeowners could genuinely trust with a major home investment. Here’s how that process worked from the initial search through to the final list.

Initial Data Collection

The starting point was building a broad list from multiple sources at once. Contractor directories, Google Business profiles, review platforms including Yelp and Houzz, and official company websites were all pulled together to create a long list of roofing services operating in or near Huntington and greater Long Island.

No contractor was excluded at this stage. The goal was to cast a wide net before applying filters.

Shortlisting Phase

The longlist was then narrowed based on a few clear filters. Contractors with no verifiable online presence, no documented customer feedback, or no evidence of active operations were removed.

Review patterns were analyzed across platforms rather than relying on any single source. Contractors with thin or unverifiable review histories were dropped, regardless of how polished their websites appeared.

The shortlist kept only those with consistent, multi-source evidence of real customer engagement.

Verification of Claims

Each shortlisted contractor’s website claims were then cross-checked against independent sources. Certification claims (such as GAF Master Elite or Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status) were verified against publicly available contractor locator tools and review platform data.

Warranty terms, service area claims, and licensing numbers were checked against available records. Where claims couldn’t be substantiated through at least one external source, they were noted but not treated as confirmed.

Authority and Industry Contribution Layer

Beyond reviews and certifications, each contractor was assessed for signals of broader industry standing. BBB accreditation history, trade organization memberships, consumer protection agency listings, and mentions in local publications were all factored in.

Contractors with longer, documented histories in the community carried more weight here. Award recognition, such as Angie’s List Super Service designations, was treated as a supporting signal rather than a primary criterion.

Top-Rated Roofing Companies in Huntington: Specific Evidence

The final filter focused on evidence of roofing services and work performed in the Huntington and broader Long Island service area. Dedicated service pages for local neighborhoods, verified reviews mentioning Long Island locations, and documented project counts in the region were all considered.

Contractors without clear geographic evidence of serving the Huntington market were flagged. The final list reflects only those with documented presence, verified credentials, and enough customer feedback to support a confident recommendation.

How to Choose the Right Top-Rated Roofing Companies In Huntington

Choosing a roofing company in Huntington comes down to more than price. Here are the factors that actually determine whether the job goes well.

• Industry/Domain Experience: Look for contractors with documented years of work in Long Island’s climate. Coastal wind loads and freeze-thaw cycles aren’t universal roofing problems, and local experience with those conditions matters.
• Features and Service Range: The best contractors handle more than just shingle replacement. Gutter work, flashing, and chimney services from one licensed team keep your project cleaner and reduce coordination risk.
• Pricing Structure: Get at least three written quotes and make sure they specify the material grade. Two quotes can look identical on price but use materials with completely different lifespans.
• Results Measurement: Ask about warranty terms upfront. A strong contractor will clearly separate manufacturer warranty coverage from their own labor warranty, and both should be in writing.
• Industry Knowledge and Compliance: Verify that the contractor is familiar with Huntington and Suffolk County building permit requirements. Any roof replacement without the proper permits can create problems when you sell the home.

Bottom Line

Roofing is one of those investments where the cheapest quote rarely ends up being the cheapest outcome. The contractors on this list were chosen because they combine verifiable credentials, real customer feedback, and genuine local experience.

Smart Choice Contractors stands out for Long Island homeowners, but the right fit depends on your project scope. As weather events become more frequent on Long Island, having a trusted contractor relationship in place before the next storm is the smartest move a homeowner can make.

Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links, meaning that at no additional cost to you, I will receive a very small commission if you click through and make a purchase. These links help to pay the editorial costs of writing a blog. For more information, please read my full affiliate disclosure here.

I also use Artificial Intelligence Image generators to create some of my images. These are to show you examples of my ideas and inspiration when I cannot produce the real images myself.